What Auto Journalists Really Drive and How It Affects You
Thursday, July 15th, 2010Buy a new car and you’ve likely pulled reviews and insights from a variety of automotive journalists, as well as research from PSCars.com and other sites. While I write about cars, I don’t drive a high-end sports car. Most auto journalists don’t.
It’s economics to be honest. None of us (BBC Top Gear presenters excluded) are struggling to make ends meet on a six or seven-figure income. In fact, most of the reviews you see are written by journalists who spend 2-4 days with a $150,000 Aston Martin but come home to a late model Volvo.
They’re not lying to you. After all, do you really get excited about long-term road tests of 2006 Mitsubishi Galants with milkshake stains on the back seat? Maybe not.
Consider this one auto writer’s mea culpa. I’ve owned three cars and have managed some feats in them that outstrip anything a writer ever noted or a manufacturer recommended.
1996 Pontiac Grand Am GT coupe:
This was a family hand-me-down that had more than 190,000 miles on the clock when I got behind the wheel. A standard transmission matched engine to wheels, and it was still on the original clutch.
That old clutch taught me to master the gas and third pedals on hill starts. The Grand Am was a bad car, and ugly. To make it go anywhere was akin to coaxing a mule in a Western movie. Prior to totaling it, the Grand Am showed me the bottom end of cars, but also how to maintain near beaters.
2003 Chevrolet Cavalier LS Sport coupe:
My first new car, the Cavalier was optioned out, but as most writers will tell you, that’s like putting lipstick on a pig.
On the other hand, I can safely say that a two-door Chevrolet Cavalier will carry an entire dorm room of gear from New Jersey to Florida. In fact, while it received poor marks for capacity, I fit a desktop, peripherals, weeks of clothing and even some furniture all through extreme weather on a 1,000+ mile stretch. It proved not all expectations were correct.
Repair jobs were also easy. A minor fender bender left my front bumper gaping and scraping the pavement, a problem solved with $3 in nuts and bolts from a home improvement store. Maintenance costs weren’t very high outside of that during its 90,000 mile lifespan either.
2008 Subaru Impreza 2.5i sedan:
The only option on this are deep floor mats to capture mud. But this car can carry a disassembled futon, full size bed and mattress on top with the confidence you need on snowy roads. My proof came on a country byway where I was going 35 miles per hour comfortably as a Hyundai Accent skidded sideways at half the speed.
This is my current daily driver. It’s docile in bad weather, and the weight and all-wheel drive aren’t power robbers when you keep the engine in its sweet spot. It can also carry more than you think, especially if you take off the spare wheel cover in the trunk and use the space in front of the rear seats.
So What?
Auto journalists have the same economic restrictions and family needs that their readers face. But our reviews are often of sterilized or idealized situations. I hope that these quick, real-world explanations show that cars don’t always match the two or three days we can spend learning about cars. Like the problems we found with initial quality reviews, at the end of the day you make your car your own.
Expect to see that mentality later this year when we compare new cars off the lot to the testers other sites used for their reviews. You can sign up for our newsletter here to be notified of our real world tests.






